Culture Fit in 2025: What Agencies Miss (and Why It's So Controversial)

Let's be honest: "culture fit" has become the hiring world's most loaded phrase. One minute you're using it to build a dream team. The next, you're getting called out for creating an echo chamber that kills creativity.

So what's actually happening here? And why are some of the sharpest agencies getting this so spectacularly wrong?

The answer isn't what you'd expect. It's not that culture fit is dead: it's that most people never understood what it meant in the first place.

The Great Culture Fit Mix-Up

Here's where most agencies go sideways: they confuse culture fit with hiring people who remind them of themselves.

Culture fit should mean finding someone whose values align with your company's core principles. But in practice? It often turns into "Would I grab a pint with this person?" or "Do they laugh at my jokes?"

That's not culture fit. That's just preference wrapped in professional language.

Real culture fit looks at whether someone shares your fundamental approach to work, collaboration, and problem-solving. Do they believe in putting clients first? Are they comfortable with your pace and communication style? Can they thrive in your specific environment?

The difference is crucial. And getting it wrong doesn't just hurt your diversity numbers: it kills your creative potential.

Why Everyone's Getting Antsy About It

The backlash against culture fit isn't coming from nowhere. There are some pretty valid reasons people are getting nervous:

It's become a discrimination smokescreen. When hiring managers say "not a culture fit," they often mean "doesn't look or sound like us." That's not just legally dodgy: it's actively harmful to building innovative teams.

It creates creative dead zones. If everyone thinks the same way, where's the spark going to come from? The best campaigns and strategies come from friction between different perspectives, not from everyone nodding along.

It shrinks your talent pool. When you're only looking for people who fit a narrow mold, you're competing with everyone else for the same small group of candidates. Meanwhile, brilliant people who could transform your agency are being overlooked.

As one creative director put it: "We hired for culture fit so hard that our brainstorms started feeling like group therapy sessions. Everyone was so aligned, nobody disagreed with anything."

What Agencies Are Actually Missing

Here's the thing most agencies don't realize: the real problem isn't culture fit itself. It's that they're using a broken definition of what culture actually means.

They mistake personality for values. Your culture isn't about whether people are extroverts or like craft beer. It's about how work gets done, how decisions get made, and what standards you hold yourself to.

They confuse comfort with compatibility. The best creative partnerships often come from people who challenge each other, not people who always agree. A little productive tension beats groupthink every time.

They ignore culture evolution. Your culture shouldn't be this static thing that new people have to squeeze into. The best hires should add something new to the mix, helping your culture grow stronger.

Think about it: if Apple only hired people who fit their 1990s culture, would they have ever created the iPhone? Sometimes the person who doesn't quite fit is exactly what you need.

The Culture Add Revolution

Smart agencies are flipping the script. Instead of asking "Do they fit our culture?" they're asking "What will they add to our culture?"

This shift changes everything. You're not looking for cultural clones: you're building a diverse team that shares core values but brings different strengths and perspectives.

Culture add means:

• Hiring the strategist who thinks differently about consumer behavior

• Bringing in the designer who challenges your aesthetic assumptions

• Finding the account manager who has a completely different approach to client relationships

The key is making sure they still align with your non-negotiables: how you treat clients, your work standards, your ethics. But beyond that? Different is good.

Skills-Based Hiring Enters the Chat

While everyone's been arguing about culture fit, something interesting has been happening. The most successful agencies have quietly been shifting toward skills-based hiring.

LinkedIn's latest data shows 75% of HR professionals believe skills-based hiring is the future. And for creative agencies, this makes perfect sense.

Can they create compelling campaigns? Do they understand your clients' industries? Can they work under pressure and meet deadlines? These are the questions that actually predict success.

One London agency we work with restructured their entire hiring process around portfolio reviews and skills assessments. Their culture? Still strong. Their creativity? Through the roof.

Getting It Right: A Practical Framework

So how do you balance team chemistry with creative diversity? Here's what the best agencies are doing:

Start with values, not vibes. Define your actual core values: not the ones on your website, but the ones that drive daily decisions. Hire for alignment with those, and you'll get the cohesion you need.

Test for skills first. Before you even think about culture, make sure they can do the job. Portfolio reviews, creative briefs, client scenario discussions: whatever it takes to prove they've got the chops.

Look for culture contributors. Instead of asking "Will they fit in?" ask "What will they bring?" The best candidates should be able to articulate what they'd add to your team dynamic.

Interview for challenges. Don't just chat about their background. Present them with real problems your agency faces and see how they approach them. Different problem-solving styles often lead to breakthrough solutions.

Include diverse voices in hiring. If your hiring panel all think alike, you'll probably hire people who think alike too. Mix up who's making the decisions.

The 2025 Reality Check

Here's what successful agencies are figuring out: culture isn't something people fit into: it's something they help create.

The agencies winning the best talent and producing the most innovative work aren't the ones with the most homogeneous cultures. They're the ones that have figured out how to blend different perspectives around shared values.

Your culture should be strong enough to give everyone direction, but flexible enough to evolve with new talent and changing times.

And honestly? The controversy around culture fit is actually doing us all a favor. It's forcing agencies to get clearer about what they actually value and what kind of team they're trying to build.

Making the Shift

Ready to upgrade your approach? Start by auditing your current hiring process. Are you screening for genuine value alignment, or just looking for people who feel familiar?

The agencies that crack this code: balancing cultural cohesion with creative diversity: will dominate the next decade. Because while everyone else is stuck in the culture fit debate, they'll be building teams that can actually solve problems their clients haven't even thought of yet.

And that's the kind of competitive advantage that actually matters.

---

Need help finding candidates who'll strengthen your culture while bringing fresh perspectives? Our team specializes in matching creative agencies with talent that drives growth, not just comfort. Get in touch to see how we're helping London's top agencies build stronger, more innovative teams.